Aesthetics/Community Character - Study Circle has Two Meetings under its Belt
By Lisa Kane DeVitto, Moderator.
The “Aesthetics/Community Character” Study Circle has completed two very
productive meetings, out of a total of five that are planned through November 2002. We
have had eleven to twelve persons at each of these meetings.
The goal of the “Aesthetics/Community Character” group is to explore the
issues raised at the June Community Kick-Off Meeting, and how they might be developed into
elements of a community plan. Key issues raised at the June Kick-Off meeting were:
“Small Town” Feeling
Seeing Water all around
Public Assembly Needs for Space
Island Identity
Community Coordination – need for more festivals
More Landscaping/fewer paved areas
Utilities Issues (power lines, canals, alleyways, garbage pick-up)
Keeping Greenspaces
Historic Preservation
Incompatible scale of buildings; residential building footprint relation to lot size
No deed restrictions on the island
Code enforcement, yard maintenance.
Our group participants have include business owners and residents (some are both), and
long-time and recent residents. To date, we have explored the larger issue of
whether Davis Island should be considered primarily a residential community, versus a
destination.
An area that needs more exploration is the relationship between the residential element, and
the other uses present on the island. The group has talked about the beauty of the original
plans and amenities as designed by developer D.P. Davis, and how those have been modified
over the years.
Some believe those original plans should be a guide to the future. A
number of the group participants either raised families on Davis Islands or grew up
here – they have emphasized the family-friendly atmosphere, areas for children
to gather and play that existed in past years, and have suggested that these
characteristics should be reclaimed.
Other issues discussed in some depth are:
Destination issue:
There are a number of ways in which Davis Islands is currently
a “destination,” both in “fixed facilities” and
events. Fixed facilities include: business district; Tampa General; Peter O.
Knight Airport; roadways used for jogging and biking; City Marina; Fishing from
Columbia; DI Yacht Club.
Event destinations include: commercial traffic, Duck
Tours, possible trolley service; bike and road races, yacht club races, and
other special events. What should plans for the future be? How do these destinations
affect our appearance and community character? Should there be more events,
fewer, or the same?
Community Character & Public Transportation:
Some do not see public transportation as relevant to DI; others do. The issue
of the trolley buses being developed downtown were discussed – some believed
that they would be helpful in connecting Davis Islander residents with the downtown business
district and cultural and recreational amenities, such as Channelside, Ybor City and the
performing arts center; others said it would be unnecessary. Some were concerned that
trolley buses would bring too much traffic to Davis Islands.
Davis Island Character/Upswing/Developable Land:
We briefly touched on the issues of height, scale, and building footprint, as
they relate to development and redevelopment of Davis Island residential areas. We hope
to focus on the Aesthetics of these issues, as opposed to the Land Use aspects. This
issue, and landscaping, were raised at the prior meeting, and we hope to return to it.
Single Family vs. Multifamily:
There are a number of differing views: some feel that single-family homes should predominate
because they create stability in the community; others liked having rentals available to add diversity
of ages and incomes. It was noted that many students/younger workers/retirees, like the
availability of rental, and that some rentals are long-term, and very stable. It was also
noted that the rental community probably contributes to the vitality of the business district.
Aesthetics & Community Character of the Business District:
There was a consensus view that there is something special about our Business District. We tried
to identify the elements that make it special/appealing, etc.
Elements that were identified were: trees; casual “old key west” style;
small scale (see original D.P. Davis Plan, with facades); setbacks to encourage
pedestrians; wide sidewalks; alleys (help with scale and are historical) –
contribute to pedestrian access; “Mom & Pop” stores vs. chains.
Which of these elements are most important, and how to encourage them, need
more discussion.
Historic Preservation/Open Space on Davis Islands:
There was some consensus that we need to preserve historic structures on Davis
Islands, but no agreement on what these structures are, or how to best preserve
them. Historic preservation seems to encompass both public and private structures,
as well as open spaces: the Swimming Pool, the parks, the Bridge, the
arch at the Marina.
Three More Meetings:
All are welcome. For the next meeting, it was suggested that we take
photos of things we like, and bring them to the next meeting to use for
discussion. We will continue with our group’s topics at the next
meeting on Thursday, October 24, 7 – 9 pm, DI Baptist Church. We
are just beginning to identify important issues, and have a long way to go.
If you are interested, or just curious, please join us!
|